Cognitive Neuroscience Society

The Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
MENUMENU
  • Home
  • Annual Meeting
        • General Information
          • What to Expect at CNS 2023
          • CNS 2023 Mobile App
          • CNS 2023 Giveaway
          • CNS 2023 Giveaway Winners
          • Accessibility at CNS
          • General Information
          • Code of Conduct
          • Dates and Deadlines
          • Hotel Reservations
          • Poster Guidelines
          • Poster Printing Discount
          • Annual Meeting Workshop Policy & Application
          • Exhibit with us!
        • Program
          • Thank you to our Partners
          • CNS 2023 Program Booklet
          • Schedule Overview
          • Program-at-a-Glance
          • CNS 30th Anniversary Dance Party
          • Keynote Address
          • George A. Miller Awardee
          • Distinguished Career Contributions Awardee
          • Young Investigator Awardees
          • CNS at 30: Perspectives on the Roots, Present, and Future of Cognitive Neuroscience
          • Invited-Symposium Sessions
          • Symposium Sessions
          • Data Blitz Session Schedule
          • Poster Schedule & Session Information
          • JoCN Travel Fellowship Award
          • GSA/PFA Award Winners
          • Workshops, Socials & Special Events
        • Registration
          • Registration
          • Registration FAQ
          • Registration Policies, Cancellations & Refunds
        • News/Press
          • CNS 2023 Press Room
          • CNS 2022 Blog
          • CNS 2021 Blog
          • CNS 2020 Blog
        • Submissions
          • 2023 Poster Printing Discount
          • Submission Requirements
          • Submit a Poster
          • Submit a Symposium
          • GSA or PFA Application
          • Data Blitz
          • Frequently Asked Submission Questions
        • Archive
          • CNS 2020 Conference Videos
          • CNS 2019 Conference Videos
          • CNS 2018 Conference Videos
          • CNS 2017 Conference Videos
          • CNS 2016 Conference Videos
          • CNS 2015 Conference Videos
          • Previous Meetings Programs & Abstracts
  • About CNS
    • Boards and Committees
    • CNS Statement: Black Lives Matter
  • Membership
    • Information and Benefits
    • Join or Renew Membership
    • Membership FAQs
    • Member Discounts
    • Newsletter
      • Submit an Announcement
      • Current Newsletter
      • Newsletter FAQs
      • Past Newsletters
  • Awards
    • George A. Miller Award
    • Fred Kavli Distinguished Career Contributions Award
    • Young Investigator Award
    • Young Investigator Award Nominations
    • 2023 YIA Nomination Form
    • JoCN Travel Fellowship Award
  • News Center
    • CNS Blog
    • CNS 2023 Press Room
    • CNS 2022 Blog
    • CNS 2021 Blog
    • CNS 2020 Blog
    • CNS 2019 Blog
    • Blog Archives
    • Quick Tips for Getting Started on Twitter
    • Media Contact
  • My CNS
  • Contact Us
post

Watch the Debate: Big Data Versus Big Theory

April 9, 2018

CNS 2018

In the neurosciences, there exists a veritable orgy of data – but is that what we need?

Will the colossal datasets we now enjoy solve the questions we seek to answer, or do we need more ‘big theory’ to provide the necessary intellectual infrastructure?

Four leading researchers, with expertise in neurophysiology, neuroimaging, artificial intelligence, language, and computation debated these big questions in “Big Data Versus Big Theory,” a special session at this year’s 25th annual CNS meeting in Boston:

  • Alona Fyshe (University in Victoria, British Columbia): Data Driven Everything
  • Eve Marder (Brandeis): The Important of the Small for Understanding the Big
  • Gary Marcus (NYU): Neuroscience, Deep Learning, and the Urgent Need for an Enriched Set of Computational Primitives
  • Jack Gallant (University of California, Berkeley): Which Presents the Biggest Obstacle to Advances in Cognitive Neuroscience Today: Lack of Theory or Lack of Data?

Watch their talks here (will play all 4 talks back-to-back plus the intro, debate, and Q&A/group discussion):

Some highlights:

Grand Ballroom is filling in for Big Theory v. Big Data. Join us for the debate! #CNS2018 @davidpoeppel pic.twitter.com/EOuCqA8J1V

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

.@davidpoeppel introducing a “wonderful cast of heroes for the epic battle” #CNS2018 #sciencedebate #Neuroscience pic.twitter.com/fY2mr8iTCX

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

.@MarderLab on the continuing importance of the small for understanding the big #CNS2018 pic.twitter.com/gCtigWGv7O

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

But building models of large numbers of neurons means either using reduced models that sacrifice biological accuracy or building models incomprehensible for real brain –@MarderLab #CNS2018#sciencedebate

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

.@alonamarie a computer scientist — I think we can play well together, I think data and theory can go hand in hand #CNS2018 pic.twitter.com/poNT74isuw

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

“If you have the data, you don’t have to have a strict theory that puts you in a corner” –@alonamarie #cns2018

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

“Let the data kill our little darlings” – nice ending from @alonamarie that merges computer science with neuroscience with #scicomm and writing 🙂 #cns2018

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

.@GaryMarcus on “The original sin: the misguided search for the one circuit that rules them all” #CNS2018 pic.twitter.com/PWzEnJnkZh

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

If we know nothing else about biology and the brain, it’s that biology is tremendously diverse at every level that we look –@GaryMarcus #cns2018

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

There’s been some progress with deep learning on perception but nothing else that goes into cognition –@GaryMarcus #cns2018#AI #ArtificialInteligence

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

.@gallantlab “This debate is silly” #CNS2018 pic.twitter.com/cpT7tKI0xa

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

The question isn’t big theory v. big data but which is the more limiting factor in progress in cognitive neuroscience right now –@gallantlab #cns2018

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

For those who can’t do these experimental designs, @gallantlab is building a tool to interrogate naturalistic data https://t.co/dERYD3PPRR #cns2018

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

Now the debate part! @davidpoeppel @MarderLab @gallantlab @alonamarie @GaryMarcus #CNS2018 pic.twitter.com/Brf44qoHmW

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

Unlike a brain, there’s no structure to the way a computer is run –@alonamarie #cns2018

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

 

Software and hardware are intertwined in the brain, unlike in a computer –@gallantlab #cns2018

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

“Chance favors prepared mind”… Mendel identified genetic factors, based on top-down, and then when others found the molecular mechanism, they could map to the factors –@GaryMarcus #cns2018

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

It’s getting really heated here. Roughly as heated as in a microprocessor running without a fan, stuck on some local minimum computation. @CogNeuroNews #CNS2018 with @davidpoeppel @gallantlab @GaryMarcus eve Marder and @Alina marie pic.twitter.com/Xb1mvqR8dU

— Jonas Obleser (@jonasobleser) March 24, 2018

This sums up the last exchange@gallantlab v. @GaryMarcus #CNS2018 pic.twitter.com/bGEQcf5jg7

— CNS News (@CogNeuroNews) March 24, 2018

By lmunoz Filed Under: featured Tagged With: cns 2018

Previous article: The Consciousness Instinct: Watch Michael Gazzaniga’s Keynote
Next article: Breaking Barriers in Brain Stimulation: Q&A with Nanthia Suthana

Recent Posts

  • Poverty: What’s the Brain Got to Do With It?
  • Unraveling Graceful Human Learning Over Time
  • Looking Forward to Understand Working Memory
  • From the Neurology Clinic to the Lab and Back Again: Addressing Frontal Lobe Syndromes
  • When Philosophical Questions Turn to Neuroscience Experimentation

Blog Archives

Quick Tips for Getting Started on Twitter

Cognitive Neuroscience Society
c/o Center for Mind and Brain
267 Cousteau Place, Davis, CA 95618
916-955-6080: for CNS Membership Questions
805-450-7490: for annual meeting questions about- registration, posters, symposium
916-409-5069: Fax Line
email: meeting@cogneurosociety.org

Recent Posts

  • Poverty: What’s the Brain Got to Do With It?
  • Unraveling Graceful Human Learning Over Time
  • Looking Forward to Understand Working Memory
  • From the Neurology Clinic to the Lab and Back Again: Addressing Frontal Lobe Syndromes
  • When Philosophical Questions Turn to Neuroscience Experimentation

Archives

Blog Archives

Previous Meeting Programs and Abstracts

Past Newsletters

All contents © Cognitive Neuroscience Society 1995-2019

Add to Calendar

Add to Calendar
04/16/2022 11:00 AM
04/16/2022 12:00 PM
America/Los_Angeles
How Prior Knowledge Shapes Encoding of New Memories
Description of the event
Grand Ballroom A
Create an Account

Login Utility