Cognitive Neuroscience Society

The Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
MENUMENU
  • Home
  • Annual Meeting
        • General Information
          • What to Expect at CNS 2023
          • CNS 2023 Mobile App
          • CNS 2023 Giveaway
          • CNS 2023 Giveaway Winners
          • Accessibility at CNS
          • General Information
          • Code of Conduct
          • Dates and Deadlines
          • Hotel Reservations
          • Poster Guidelines
          • Poster Printing Discount
          • Annual Meeting Workshop Policy & Application
          • Exhibit with us!
        • Program
          • Thank you to our Partners
          • CNS 2023 Program Booklet
          • Schedule Overview
          • Program-at-a-Glance
          • CNS 30th Anniversary Dance Party
          • Keynote Address
          • George A. Miller Awardee
          • Distinguished Career Contributions Awardee
          • Young Investigator Awardees
          • CNS at 30: Perspectives on the Roots, Present, and Future of Cognitive Neuroscience
          • Invited-Symposium Sessions
          • Symposium Sessions
          • Data Blitz Session Schedule
          • Poster Schedule & Session Information
          • JoCN Travel Fellowship Award
          • GSA/PFA Award Winners
          • Workshops, Socials & Special Events
        • Registration
          • Registration
          • Registration FAQ
          • Registration Policies, Cancellations & Refunds
        • News/Press
          • CNS 2023 Press Room
          • CNS 2022 Blog
          • CNS 2021 Blog
          • CNS 2020 Blog
        • Submissions
          • 2023 Poster Printing Discount
          • Submission Requirements
          • Submit a Poster
          • Submit a Symposium
          • GSA or PFA Application
          • Data Blitz
          • Frequently Asked Submission Questions
        • Archive
          • CNS 2020 Conference Videos
          • CNS 2019 Conference Videos
          • CNS 2018 Conference Videos
          • CNS 2017 Conference Videos
          • CNS 2016 Conference Videos
          • CNS 2015 Conference Videos
          • Previous Meetings Programs & Abstracts
  • About CNS
    • Boards and Committees
    • CNS Statement: Black Lives Matter
  • Membership
    • Information and Benefits
    • Join or Renew Membership
    • Membership FAQs
    • Member Discounts
    • Newsletter
      • Submit an Announcement
      • Current Newsletter
      • Newsletter FAQs
      • Past Newsletters
  • Awards
    • George A. Miller Award
    • Fred Kavli Distinguished Career Contributions Award
    • Young Investigator Award
    • Young Investigator Award Nominations
    • 2023 YIA Nomination Form
    • JoCN Travel Fellowship Award
  • News Center
    • CNS Blog
    • CNS 2023 Press Room
    • CNS 2023 Blog
    • CNS 2022 Blog
    • CNS 2021 Blog
    • CNS 2020 Blog
    • CNS 2019 Blog
    • Blog Archives
    • Quick Tips for Getting Started on Twitter
    • Media Contact
  • My CNS
  • Contact Us
post

Judgments of Competence Affect Anticipation of Pain

July 22, 2015

Doctor_examines_patient-1024x667Picking a new dentist or doctor can be harrowing experience. Internet reviews and word of mouth may help, but oftentimes it comes down to first impressions, maybe even just a photo online. A new study shows that these impressions of people’s competence actually affect our anticipation of pain.

“The goal of this study was to show that when others are in a position to secure our safety, we make surface-level judgments of how competent they look and this plays a role in calculating our own safety,” says Dean Mobbs of Columbia University. “This information is used to up or down regulate our anticipation of danger or, in the case of our paper, the anticipation of pain.” Essentially, he says, an inference of high competence in a given context acts as a proxy for protection and safety.

The work was inspired by the research by Alex Todorov (Princeton) and colleagues on competency perception. In one study, Todorov found that judgment of competence levels predicts U.S. congressional electoral success. The idea underlying all this work is that as our ancestors evolved, they developed the capacity to make quick inferences about others based on limited information.

“This is evolutionary viable, as accurate inferences based on physiognomy could provide important information about whom to trust, whom to hunt with and whom to mate with,” Mobbs say. “Still the jury is out on whether we have a serious capacity to do this in the same way that we can recognize more salient facial features such as kinship or even emotion.”

To test how competency judgments affect anticipation of pain, Mobbs’ team, led by grad student Ellen Tedeschi, asked participants to play a working memory task that would get increasingly more challenging over time. The researchers video-recorded their performance and took photos of their faces. They then asked two different groups of participants to rate the competence of the players based on the photos, to ensure consistency in the ratings between the groups (which there was).

The researchers then used these ratings to select 15 most and least competent-looking faces for an fMRI study. While in the fMRI, participants would view photos of players and rate their competence to perform the working memory task. Next, the participants observed a short 2-second movie of the players starting the task. The screen would then of blank for about 12 seconds and if the player made a mistake on the working memory task during this time period, the participant received an electric shock.

“Therefore during this anticipation period, the participant’s only information is how competent the player looked.,” Mobbs explains.

As published in the Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience online last month, the researchers found that the higher the participants rated the player’s competence, the less anxious they felt. “What was most exciting was the finding that the insula decreased in activity when the competent players performed the working memory task,” Mobbs saays. The insula is part of the pain network in the brain.

“Although we cannot attribute mechanism to this finding, it is clear that a part of the pain network is reduced based on the inferences of the players’ competence and, by proxy, their ability to perform the task without making mistake,” he says.

This work has important implications for understanding connections between anxiety and stress reduction in patients. “For example, believing that your doctor is competent may play a critical role in one’s trust in their clinical judgments and consequently result in faster recovery,” Mobbs says.

Mobbs’ team is also looking at the effects of reputation on this phenomenon. “We hope to understand the behavioral and neural systems that result in fear reduction and safety in the context of social interaction,” he says.

-Lisa M.P. Munoz

The paper, “Inferences of Others’ Competence Reduces Anticipation of Pain When Under Threat” by Ellen Tedeschi, Jochen Weber, Charlotte Prévost, Walter Mischel and Dean Mobbs, was published online in Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience on June 23, 2015.

By lmunoz Filed Under: Uncategorized

Previous article: Distinguishing Consonant Sounds in Noise Predicts Reading Ability in Preschoolers
Next article: How We Sharpen Attention on the Fly in Response to Incentives

Recent Posts

  • CNS 2023: Day 4 Highlights
  • Psychedelics and Cognition: A New Look
  • CNS 2023: Day 3 Highlights
  • CNS 2023: Day 2 Highlights
  • Forget About It: Investigating How We Purge Thoughts from Our Minds

Blog Archives

Quick Tips for Getting Started on Twitter

Cognitive Neuroscience Society
c/o Center for Mind and Brain
267 Cousteau Place, Davis, CA 95618
916-955-6080: for CNS Membership Questions
805-450-7490: for annual meeting questions about- registration, posters, symposium
916-409-5069: Fax Line
email: meeting@cogneurosociety.org

Recent Posts

  • CNS 2023: Day 4 Highlights
  • Psychedelics and Cognition: A New Look
  • CNS 2023: Day 3 Highlights
  • CNS 2023: Day 2 Highlights
  • Forget About It: Investigating How We Purge Thoughts from Our Minds

Archives

Blog Archives

Previous Meeting Programs and Abstracts

Past Newsletters

All contents © Cognitive Neuroscience Society 1995-2019

Add to Calendar

Add to Calendar
04/16/2022 11:00 AM
04/16/2022 12:00 PM
America/Los_Angeles
How Prior Knowledge Shapes Encoding of New Memories
Description of the event
Grand Ballroom A
Create an Account

Login Utility